Skip to content
Archive

Post

Back to deliverables

7warroom
战斗室
@7warroom

CNN把美国麻疹升到35年高点这口锅,直接推到卫生与公众服务部长小罗伯特·肯尼迪面前。 主持人达娜·巴什给他的身份牌也很熟练:全球最有名的疫苗怀疑者。这个打法太媒体了,公共卫生问题先不看边界、不看基准线、不看同一波疫情在别国怎么走,先把镜头怼到一个人脸上。 肯尼迪没跟她喊口号,直接把账本摊开。 他说这是国际性疫情,美国处理得比其他国家好。按他的说法,墨西哥人均麻疹病例是美国的15倍,加拿大是4倍,英格兰是2倍。然后他反问一句:“那些麻疹疫情是我造成的吗?” 这一下,主持人的框架就漏风了。 如果麻疹暴发是肯尼迪个人影响力造成的,那加拿大、英格兰、墨西哥那几本账也得一起算到他头上。要是算不上,那美国这本账就不能只靠一张“疫苗怀疑者”的名片结案。 肯尼迪还把锅往前推了一层。他说福奇日记里提过,新冠封锁期间孩子错过接种,后来会带来麻疹大规模暴发;他说现在感染的,正是本该18个月接种MMR却没接种的年龄组。他还说,南卡、德州、犹他、弗吉尼亚的疫情,卫生部门派疫情情报服务队、联系州长后,已经被很快拦住。 这不是医学建议,也不是替任何人拍板健康决定。这里只看新闻框架。 CNN想问责,可以。公共卫生本来就该问责。可问责不能像饭桌上找背锅亲戚:谁名声最刺耳,谁坐主位挨骂。 肯尼迪最后补了一句,他从未质疑过MMR疫苗的有效性。 这句话要是放在CNN给他贴的那张身份牌旁边,画面就很好看了:一边是标签,一边是基准线。主持人拿标签上桌,肯尼迪拿别国疫情数字结账。

· 1.2K Views

5 Reposts 9 Likes 3 Bookmarks
replies reposts likes
2 replies collected
jeff lee @Jefflee8084Lee ·

CNN pinned the spike in U.S. measles cases to a 35-year high squarely on Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr.'s doorstep. Host Dana Bash slapped his name tag on with practiced ease: the world's most notorious vaccine skeptic. This play is so media—public health issues get framed without looking at borders, without baselines, without seeing how the same outbreak plays out in other countries, just shoving the camera right in one person's face. Kennedy didn't shout slogans back at her. He just laid out the ledger. He said it's an international outbreak, and the U.S. is handling it better than other countries. By his account, Mexico's per capita measles cases are 15 times higher than the U.S., Canada's 4 times, England's 2 times. Then he fired back: "Did I cause those measles outbreaks?"