Skip to content
Archive
← r/Forex
1
100%
u/david19790 20 hours ago Charts and Setups

does anyone actually change anything for cpi or is it mostly theatre

genuine question because every thread this week is people announcing they're sitting out and then posting entries at 8:35 anyway. the thing that made me stop caring about the print itself was realising my stop isnt really a stop during it. spread widens, liquidity goes for a few seconds, and the fill comes back wherever it comes back. a 20 pip stop that fills 35 pips away is 1.75x the risk you thought you had, on a trade you sized assuming the number was fixed. so "im fine, i have a stop" isnt actually a plan for tomorrow morning, its a plan for a normal tuesday. which leaves two honest options as far as i can tell. flat before the release, or sized small enough that filling through your stop is survivable rather than account ending. both are fine. what doesnt work is deciding which one at 8:29 with a position already on, because thats when you're most invested in the answer being the comfortable one. mine goes flat before scheduled releases because its a condition in the code rather than something i weigh up on the morning, and honestly the best part isnt the risk saved, its that i dont plan my week around a calendar anymore. tomorrow looks like any other day for me and it took years to get there. so whats everyone actually doing. flat, sized down, or trading it on purpose with a strategy built for it
4 comments held Reddit says 0 on reddit ↗
  1. u/rforex-modtools moderator pinned 1 20 hours ago
    Price action and technical analysis cover a range of chart-based tools — from candlestick patterns and market structure to indicators and statistical methods for timing entries and exits. The community wiki covers both approaches and how they're used by working traders. Resources: **Price Action Analysis** | **Technical Analysis**
  2. u/Relevant-Owl-8455 1 16 hours ago
    Depends on your system. If you're "scalping" trading CPI is not a good idea... If you're trading swing... It normaly doesn't matter if you leave your trades open during strong news events. EXCEPT if the price is already near your stops... it could slip you deep. :) Again, your trading plan should have answers for these scenarios.
  3. u/STPtrading_EN 1 14 hours ago
    honestly this is the take I've landed on too. the stop-during-news thing gets glossed over so much, everyone talks about "I have my stop" like it's static, but during a print your fill isn't where your stop is, it's wherever liquidity decides to give it back to you. flat before scheduled high-impact stuff isn't fear, it's just accounting for slippage you can't control.
  4. u/STPtrading_EN 1 14 hours ago
    Going flat before scheduled releases is underrated. People focus on the stop-loss but forget the fill during a spike can land way past it, so the 'I have a stop' logic breaks down exactly when it matters most.